A 42-year-old man presents with a 3-year history of progressive bilateral hearing loss and recurrent episodes of vertigo with imbalance in the dark. Audiometry shows bilateral high-frequency sensorineural hearing loss with downsloping pattern. Caloric irrigation reveals bilateral reduced responses. His father had similar symptoms starting in his 40s. The clinical presentation marked as **A** in the diagram — progressive high-frequency SNHL with bilateral vestibulopathy — is most consistent with which genetic disorder?
A. DFNA9 (COCH gene mutation on chromosome 14q12)
B. Bilateral Menière's disease with asymmetric presentation
C. Presbycusis with coincidental bilateral vestibular dysfunction
D. DFNA1 (DIAPH1 gene mutation causing progressive low-frequency SNHL)
Explanation
Why DFNA9 (COCH gene mutation on chromosome 14q12) is right
DFNA9 is the most common autosomal dominant cause of late-onset progressive sensorineural hearing loss with vestibular dysfunction, presenting in the 4th–6th decades. The COCH gene (chromosome 14q12) encodes cochlin, the most abundant protein of the inner ear extracellular matrix. Pathogenic missense mutations cause misfolding and dominant-negative deposition of mutant cochlin as eosinophilic aggregates in the spiral ligament and vestibular labyrinth. The clinical hallmark is insidious onset with bilateral progressive high-frequency downsloping SNHL combined with bilateral peripheral vestibulopathy (instability in the dark, oscillopsia, recurrent vertigo), exactly matching the presentation marked A. The positive family history (father affected in 4th decade) confirms autosomal dominant inheritance. This patient requires genetic testing (COCH sequencing), annual audiometry and vestibular reassessment, hearing aids or cochlear implantation as needed, vestibular rehabilitation, and genetic counseling for his children (50% recurrence risk).
Why each distractor is wrong
DFNA1 (DIAPH1 gene mutation causing progressive low-frequency SNHL): DFNA1 presents with progressive low-frequency hearing loss, not the high-frequency downsloping pattern seen here. DFNA1 is not associated with significant vestibular dysfunction. This does not match the clinical presentation marked A.
Bilateral Menière's disease with asymmetric presentation: Menière's disease is typically unilateral and fluctuating with episodic vertigo, hearing loss, and tinnitus. Although bilateral Menière's can occur, it is rare, not familial, and does not show the progressive downsloping SNHL pattern or bilateral vestibulopathy seen in DFNA9. The strong family history and bilateral progressive pattern favor DFNA9.
Presbycusis with coincidental bilateral vestibular dysfunction: Presbycusis is age-related bilateral symmetric SNHL (usually flat or low-frequency predominant) without a genetic cause and without familial clustering. The early age of onset (42 years), high-frequency downsloping pattern, and positive family history are inconsistent with presbycusis. Bilateral vestibular dysfunction is not a feature of presbycusis.
High-YieldNEET PG
DFNA9 (COCH) = bilateral progressive high-frequency SNHL + bilateral vestibulopathy + autosomal dominant inheritance + late onset (30s–40s) = most common genetic cause of this phenotype; mimic is bilateral Menière's, but DFNA9 is familial, bilateral from onset, and progresses to bilateral vestibulopathy rather than fluctuating.
Cummings Otolaryngology 7e; Smith RJH GeneReviews — DFNA9 COCH 2024
Practice similar questions
Sign up free to access AI-powered MCQ practice with detailed explanations and adaptive learning.