## Why Lisfranc injury with ligamentous disruption; ORIF or primary arthrodesis indicated for unstable displacement is right The clinical presentation—low-energy twist on a planted foot, inability to bear weight, plantar ecchymosis (highly specific), and the radiographic finding of a "fleck sign" (small bone fragment between the 1st and 2nd metatarsal bases representing avulsion of the Lisfranc ligament)—is pathognomonic for a Lisfranc injury. This represents disruption of the tarsometatarsal joint complex, not a 5th metatarsal fracture. The widening between the 1st and 2nd metatarsal bases confirms instability. Per Gray's Anatomy and Apley's Orthopedics, unstable or displaced Lisfranc injuries (>2 mm displacement) require ORIF or primary arthrodesis; primary arthrodesis is increasingly favored for ligamentous injuries due to superior long-term functional outcomes. Missed or inadequately treated Lisfranc injuries lead to chronic midfoot pain, deformity, and post-traumatic arthritis requiring salvage procedures. ## Why each distractor is wrong - **Pseudo-Jones fracture; treat with weight-bearing shoe and symptomatic care**: This describes an avulsion fracture of the 5th metatarsal tuberosity by the peroneus brevis tendon, which typically heals well with conservative management. However, the clinical presentation (plantar ecchymosis, widening between 1st and 2nd MT bases, fleck sign) and inability to bear weight are inconsistent with a simple tuberosity avulsion and instead indicate a more serious midfoot ligamentous injury (Lisfranc). - **Stress fracture of the 5th metatarsal diaphysis; non-weight-bearing cast for 6-8 weeks**: Stress fractures present with progressive pain from repetitive overuse (runners, dancers) and are initially radiographically occult, becoming visible only with periosteal reaction on later films or MRI/bone scan. This acute traumatic presentation with fleck sign and widening is not consistent with a stress fracture. - **Jones fracture at the metadiaphyseal junction; requires intramedullary screw fixation**: A Jones fracture is a transverse fracture at the 5th metatarsal metadiaphyseal junction with high nonunion risk due to watershed blood supply. While it may require IMN fixation in athletes, the radiographic findings (fleck sign, widening between 1st and 2nd MT bases, plantar ecchymosis) and the mechanism (twist on planted foot) are diagnostic of Lisfranc injury, not a 5th metatarsal fracture. **High-Yield:** Plantar ecchymosis + fleck sign (small bone fragment between 1st and 2nd MT bases) + widening of the 1st–2nd MT gap = Lisfranc injury until proven otherwise; weight-bearing X-rays are essential to detect displacement; missed Lisfranc injuries cause chronic disability. [cite: Gray's Anatomy 42e Ch 84; Apley's System of Orthopedics and Fractures 10e]
Sign up free to access AI-powered MCQ practice with detailed explanations and adaptive learning.